# Validator expectations for the conversion contract model/profiles/gff3-contig.yaml.
# Kept out of the contract so its checksum in the conversion report stays stable.
profile: gff3-contig/4.0.0
# Independent validator observations; reproduce with just validity-check.
validation:
  scope: Exact rule sets for the listed retained corpus inputs, including negative controls. These are
    validator observations, not conversion-support claims.
  genometools:
    status: measured
    expected_failures:
      attribute-assignment: The deliberately unescaped semicolon leaves an attribute without an equals
        sign.
      illegal-phase: The deliberately malformed CDS fixture has phase 3.
      inconsistent-id-type: The deliberately duplicated ID joins rows of different feature types.
      missing-version: 'The required first-line ##gff-version directive is absent. GenomeTools stops here;
        later defects are not measured.'
      start-after-end: The deliberately malformed feature starts after its end.
      unsupported-version: 'The JGI isolate GeneMark file declares ##gff-version 2 while its attributes
        use GFF3 tag=value syntax. GenomeTools stops here; later defects are not measured.'
      unresolved-parent: The deliberately malformed Parent value refers to an absent ID.
  gff3toolkit:
    status: measured
    expected_failures:
      Ema0003: The reversed-coordinate control is reported outside its parent boundaries.
      Ema0005: The RefSeq chromosome contains pseudogene children that this QC rule rejects.
      Emr0003: The duplicate-ID control is reported as a duplicate.
      Esf0001: The Cellulophaga phage phi17:2 RefSeq GFF3 has a pseudogenic_tRNA, which QC suggests
        changing to pseudogene.
      Esf0003: QC reports any strand other than + or - as missing. That covers . in the protein-relative
        Pfam hits and unstranded annotation families, and the numeric 1 and -1 of the IMG pipeline 4.14.0
        Bacillus GFF.
      Esf0014: 'The first line lacks ##gff-version. The source is preserved without adding it.'
      Esf0018: The reversed-coordinate control starts after its end.
      Esf0019: 'The JGI isolate GeneMark file declares ##gff-version 2.'
      Esf0022: Some NMDC and JGI isolate search files have an empty source column; QC requires a
        dot.
      Esf0025: The IMG pipeline 4.14.0 isolate GFF writes strand as 1 (2,062 rows) and -1 (2,631 rows)
        rather than + and -.
      Esf0026: The deliberately malformed CDS fixture has phase 3.
      Esf0029: The unescaped-semicolon control has a bare attribute rather than one equals sign.
      Esf0031: The unescaped-semicolon control also produces an empty attribute value.
      Esf0032: A key repeats within one row, such as shortened in a JGI isolate structural roll-up
        and LowScore in the IMG pipeline 4.14.0 GFF.
      Esf0036: QC reports literal commas in attributes, including partial and product. This is recorded
        as a tool result, not a universal dialect prohibition.
      Esf0041: Capitalized keys that GFF3 does not reserve, such as Type, Model and RNA_Class_ID in the
        IMG pipeline 4.14.0 GFF and D-score in the JGI isolate SignalP file.
  agat:
    status: blocked
    expected_failures: null
    reason: No measured rule list. See analyses/format-validation/agat-blocker.json for the 2026-09-25
      macOS arm64 dependency failure.
  cases:
    nmdc-cath-funfam:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
    nmdc-crt:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
    nmdc-cog:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0022
    nmdc-genemark:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0036
    nmdc-ko-ec:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
    nmdc-prodigal:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0036
    nmdc-rfam:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0036
    nmdc-smart:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0022
    nmdc-superfam:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
    nmdc-structural-annotation:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0014
    nmdc-tigrfam:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0022
    nmdc-trna:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0014
    ncbi-refseq-GCF_000819615-1:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit: []
    ncbi-refseq-GCF_000840245-1:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0036
    derived-cds-phase-illegal:
      genometools:
      - illegal-phase
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0026
    derived-dangling-parent:
      genometools:
      - unresolved-parent
      gff3toolkit: []
    derived-duplicate-id:
      genometools:
      - inconsistent-id-type
      gff3toolkit:
      - Emr0003
    derived-no-version-pragma:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0014
    derived-start-after-end:
      genometools:
      - start-after-end
      gff3toolkit:
      - Ema0003
      - Esf0018
    derived-unescaped-semicolon:
      genometools:
      - attribute-assignment
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0029
      - Esf0031
    derived-cds-phase-biologically-wrong:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit: []
    derived-multiple-parents:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit: []
    derived-unescaped-semicolon-silent:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit: []
    nmdc-biosample-structural:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0036
    refseq-coelicolor-chromosome:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit:
      - Ema0005
      - Esf0036
    derived-actinorhodin-excerpt:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0036
    jgi-img-clostridium-cath-funfam:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
    jgi-img-clostridium-cleavage-sites:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0041
    jgi-img-clostridium-cog:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0022
    jgi-img-clostridium-crt:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
    jgi-img-clostridium-genemark:
      genometools:
      - unsupported-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0019
    jgi-img-clostridium-ko-ec:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0036
    jgi-img-clostridium-pfam:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
    jgi-img-clostridium-prodigal:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit: []
    jgi-img-clostridium-rfam:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0036
    jgi-img-clostridium-rfam-misc-bind-misc-feature-regulatory:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0036
    jgi-img-clostridium-rfam-ncrna-tmrna:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0014
    jgi-img-clostridium-rfam-rrna:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0014
    jgi-img-clostridium-smart:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0022
    jgi-img-clostridium-structural-annotation:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0032
      - Esf0036
    jgi-img-clostridium-supfam:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
    jgi-img-clostridium-tigrfam:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0022
    jgi-img-clostridium-tmh:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
    jgi-img-clostridium-trna:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0014
    jgi-img-bacillus-assembled-gff:
      genometools:
      - missing-version
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
      - Esf0014
      - Esf0025
      - Esf0032
      - Esf0041
    jgi-img-bacillus-taxon-gff:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0036
    refseq-viral-nc-067194-1:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit: []
    refseq-viral-nc-001497-2:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0036
    refseq-viral-nc-021798-1:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0001
    refseq-viral-nc-014649-1:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit: []
    refseq-viral-nc-001417-2:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit: []
    refseq-viral-nc-003291-2:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit: []
    refseq-viral-nc-001421-2:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit: []
    refseq-viral-nc-001890-1:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit: []
    ensembl-scer-r64-mito-gff3:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
    bakta-mgenitalium-g37-gff3:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0003
    prokka-mgenitalium-g37-gff3:
      genometools: []
      gff3toolkit:
      - Esf0036
